Soft Italian Christmas Cookies

In many Italian-American households, the arrival of December signals one very specific thing: the production of the legendary “cookie tray.” While there may be pizzelles, biscotti, and rainbow cookies, no platter is complete without the quintessential Italian Christmas Cookie. These are not your average crispy sugar cookies; they are soft, pillowy, and almost cake-like in texture, carrying a nostalgic aroma of sweet almond and butter. Known by various names like Anginetti or Tarallini Dolci, these treats have been passed down through generations, evolving slightly in each kitchen but always retaining that signature domed shape and colorful sprinkle garnish. Whether you grew up watching your Nonna glaze these by the dozen or you are starting a new tradition today, this recipe captures the authentic taste and texture that makes these cookies the undisputed star of the holiday season.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

You will fall in love with these Italian Christmas Cookies because they offer the perfect balance of simplicity and festive flair. Unlike complex pastries that require hours of chilling or intricate decorating, these cookies come together with basic pantry staples and a straightforward mixing process. The texture is truly unique—soft enough to melt in your mouth but sturdy enough to hold a thick, luscious glaze. The use of almond extract provides a sophisticated sweetness that distinguishes them from standard vanilla cookies. Plus, they are incredibly versatile; you can easily double the batch for a cookie swap, and their festive appearance with bright sprinkles brings instant holiday cheer to any table or gift box.

What Is an Italian Christmas Cookie?

An Italian Christmas Cookie is a traditional, soft-baked treat deeply rooted in Southern Italian pastry traditions. Often referred to as “Italian Butter Cookies” or “Anginetti,” they are characterized by a “drop” style dough that results in a tender, muffin-like crumb. Historically, these cookies were often flavored with anise (black licorice flavor), but the modern Italian-American version frequently utilizes almond or lemon extract to appeal to broader palates. They are defined by their opaque white glaze—a simple mixture of powdered sugar and milk—and a generous coating of nonpareils or sprinkles. In Italian culture, these cookies represent hospitality and the joy of sharing homemade gifts during the “Natale” season.

Ingredients Overview

To achieve the perfect bake, understanding your ingredients is key to E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) in the kitchen.

• All-Purpose Flour: This provides the structural foundation. Unlike bread flour, all-purpose keeps the cookies tender rather than chewy.
• Baking Powder: A full tablespoon might seem like a lot, but it is necessary to create that signature lift and cake-like interior.
• Unsalted Butter: Using butter at room temperature allows for proper creaming with the sugar, which aerates the dough and contributes to the soft texture.
• Granulated Sugar: Provides sweetness and helps the cookies brown slightly on the bottom.
• Eggs: These act as a binder and provide moisture. Using room-temperature eggs ensures they incorporate seamlessly without curdling the butter.
• Almond Extract: This is the soul of the cookie. It provides a warm, nutty aroma that defines the flavor profile.
• Powdered Sugar & Milk: These form the base of the glaze. The powdered sugar must be sifted if it’s lumpy to ensure a smooth finish on your cookies.

Ingredient Substitutions & Tips

While the classic almond version is beloved, you can customize these cookies easily. For a more traditional “Old World” flavor, swap the almond extract for anise extract. If you prefer a brighter, citrusy profile, use lemon extract and add a teaspoon of fresh lemon zest to the dough. For those with gluten sensitivities, a high-quality 1:1 gluten-free flour blend works surprisingly well in this recipe due to the high moisture content. If you find yourself out of milk for the glaze, heavy cream will yield a richer, more opaque icing, while water can be used for a more translucent, thinner coating.

Step-by-Step Instructions

1. Prepare the Dry Base: Start by whisking your all-purpose flour, baking powder, and salt in a medium-sized bowl. This ensures the leavening agent is evenly distributed, preventing any uneven rising during the baking process.

2. Creaming the Fats: In a large bowl or a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat your softened butter and granulated sugar. You want to see the color turn pale and the texture become fluffy—this usually takes about 2-3 minutes on medium speed.

3. Emulsifying the Liquids: Add your eggs one at a time. It is vital to wait until the first egg is fully disappeared into the creamed butter before adding the second. Pour in your almond extract and mix briefly.

4. Combining the Dough: Turn your mixer to low and gradually add the flour mixture. Mix only until you see no more white streaks of flour. Overmixing at this stage can lead to a tough cookie, so keep it brief!

5. The Chilling Phase: For the most beautiful, rounded “ball” shapes, cover the dough and refrigerate for at least one hour. This firms up the butter and prevents the cookies from spreading too thin in the oven.

6. Baking to Perfection: Preheat your oven to 350°F. Roll the dough into 1-inch balls (about the size of a walnut). Place them 2 inches apart on a parchment-lined sheet. Bake for 8-10 minutes. The tops should look set and pale, while the bottoms should be just barely golden.

7. Glazing and Decorating: Once the cookies are completely cool, whisk together your glaze ingredients. Dip the tops, let the excess drip off, and immediately top with sprinkles before the glaze sets.

Expert Baking Tips

Temperature is everything when it comes to Italian Christmas Cookies. If your butter is too cold, it won’t cream properly; if it’s melted, the cookies will be greasy. Aim for “cool room temperature” where your finger leaves an indent but doesn’t sink through. Additionally, the consistency of your glaze is a fine art. If the glaze is too thin, it will run off the cookie and look transparent. If it’s too thick, it will be difficult to dip. Aim for the consistency of heavy glue. If it feels too stiff, add milk half a teaspoon at a time until it reaches a smooth, pourable state.

The Secret to the Perfect Glaze

The “Special Section” of this recipe is the glazing technique. To get that professional food-blogger look, you want a thick, white, opaque cap on your cookie. The trick is to dip the cookie upside down into the bowl of glaze, swirl it slightly, and pull it straight up. Let the excess drip for a count of three, then quickly flip it over. This movement helps the glaze settle into a smooth, even layer. Always apply your sprinkles within 30 seconds of glazing, as the high sugar content causes the icing to form a “skin” quickly, which prevents the sprinkles from sticking.

Serving Suggestions

These cookies are best served on a large, festive platter alongside other Italian classics. They pair beautifully with a hot cup of espresso or a glass of dessert wine like Vin Santo. For a modern twist, serve them in a shallow bowl alongside a scoop of vanilla or pistachio gelato. They also make wonderful “party favors”—simply stack three or four in a clear cellophane bag and tie with a red ribbon for a thoughtful, handmade holiday gift.

Storage & Make-Ahead Tips

Italian Christmas Cookies stay fresh for up to 5 days when stored in an airtight container at room temperature. Because they are soft, avoid stacking them too high before the glaze has completely hardened (which can take 2-4 hours). If you want to get ahead of the holiday rush, you can freeze the unglazed baked cookies for up to 3 months. When ready to serve, thaw them at room temperature and apply a fresh batch of glaze and sprinkles for that “just-baked” appearance.

FAQs

Can I make these cookies without chilling the dough?
Yes, you can skip the chilling process if you are in a hurry. However, the dough will be stickier to handle, and the cookies will spread more in the oven, resulting in a flatter, wider shape rather than a tall, rounded dome.

Why did my cookies come out dry?
Dry cookies are usually the result of overbaking or overmeasuring the flour. Ensure you “spoon and level” your flour into the measuring cup rather than scooping directly from the bag, and pull the cookies out as soon as the bottoms are lightly golden.

Is almond extract better than anise?
This is purely a matter of preference! Anise is the traditional Italian flavor, tasting like black licorice. Almond is the most popular modern variation. You can also use vanilla or lemon depending on your taste.

How do I prevent the sprinkles from bleeding color into the glaze?
Wait until the cookies are completely cool before glazing. If the cookie is warm, the glaze stays wet too long, causing the dye in the sprinkles to run.

Can I use a different type of milk for the glaze?
Absolutely. Almond milk, soy milk, or even water will work, though dairy milk or cream provides the most opaque, white finish.

Baking Italian Christmas Cookies is about more than just a recipe; it’s about embracing the warmth and generosity of the holiday season. These soft, almond-scented treats are a testament to the beauty of simple ingredients coming together to create something truly special. Whether you are an experienced baker or a beginner, these cookies offer a foolproof way to bring a taste of Italy into your home. Happy baking and Buon Natale!

Print